Home
YOUR Tips
Ask the Expert
Affiliates
Weight Loss Blog
[?] Subscribe To This Site

XML RSS
Add to Google
Add to My Yahoo!
Add to My MSN
Subscribe with Bloglines

 

Supplements

by Catherine
(Hamilton, Ontario, Canada)

I enjoyed the article. Much of it I already knew but I did pick up some good pointers.

I completely disagree with this statement. "It is impossible to get all the nutrients your body requires just from food. Accordingly, it is necessary to take supplements."

From my viewpoint, the earth provides the foods necessary to sustain life and enjoy excellent health. They have to be sourced out, prepared and eaten properly. Our society in North America has generally not been taught the proper way to great nutrition. Naturally, the advice from some is to take supplements. Read: spend my money on products that you endorse. It always comes down to money and that's just the way it is.

For me, I do not take any supplements. I am a 50 yr old female who takes no prescription (or recreational for that matter) drugs. I exercise regularly and prepare all my meals for consumption throughout the day. I do eat in restaurants several times a month but am choosy on my menu selections. I drink red wine a couple of times a week (a glass or two, used to do the whole bottle!) and beer with friends every once in a while. I never eat fast-food. I never buy pre-packaged products (I shop the perimeter of the grocery store!) and limit red meat and little or no potatoes (even though I love them). Grains and vegetables, lean meats along with some fruit and dairy make up the bulk of my diet. And I read, read, read up on nutrition. ie sugar and sodium awareness.

I recently completed a medical for my aviation license and when I called the doc for my
blood test results she said, 'whatever you're doing, keep doing it.’

This is my viewpoint on your point about daily supplements.

Thanks for reading.

Comments for
Supplements

Average Rating starstarstarstarstar

Click here to add your own comments

Sep 20, 2010
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Why I believe in supplements (part 2)
by: Steve

Myself and my business partner Adrian run a small supplement company here in Perth Western Australia and we design the products in our range ourselves. Plus, we base our formulations on published scientific research.

With the amount of reading you do, you should also be well aware of the potential harm grain foods and dairy products may have on the human body. This is unless of course you've been reading the information (propaganda) that comes from the companies and promoters of these products.

I have written an article on this topic that you may find interesting. It is in the Nutrition Articles section and discusses the USDA Food Pyramid history.

That information was the main reason why I gave up studying nutrition at university after finishing my first degree in human movement and human biology.

When it comes to your doctor giving you a 'clean bill of health', well, with all due respect, the basic tests they perform for a standard blood test are far from comprehensive and should always be taken with a grain of salt.

Nevertheless Catherine, keep up the good work! It has obviously worked well for you so far. Also, thanks for taking the time to comment on the article.

I appreciate everyone who makes the effort to provide their thoughts on the articles and even if we don't happen to agree on certain points, that's okay! We can disagree agreeably!

All the very best.

Regards,

Steve.

Sep 20, 2010
Rating
starstarstarstarstar
Why I believe in supplements
by: Steve

Hi Catherine,

Great to hear from you. Thanks for your comments and feedback. This is quite a lengthy reply so I will break it up into 2 parts.

You're absolutely right! It is possible to get all the nutrients you need from food:

o if you eat food from all the food groups,
o if the food was grown in mineral-rich soils,
o if they didn't use chemical pesticides and herbicides when the food was growing,
o if it wasn't picked before it was ripe,
o if it wasn't packaged or processed in any way and
o if it wasn't left on the shelf in the store for days or weeks at a time,

If you can guarantee all of these factors then yes, it is possible to eat a balanced diet.

Accordingly I have modified the article to read: 'It is virtually impossible to get all the nutrients your body requires just from food.', as a result of your feedback.

I believe supplements have their place. They should certainly not replace food or a good exercise program.

However, I strongly disagree with your comment: 'It always comes down to money and that's just the way it is.'

I am passionate about helping people and that is why I have been in the health and fitness for over 20 years! I can tell you straight that if it was just about the money I would certainly not be in this industry!

If you choose not to take supplements then that is your prerogative. However, if you have done so much reading as you say you've done then you would be well aware of the wealth of proven, scientific research that demonstrates the value of taking supplements; fish oil is just one example. How about the benefits of antioxidants, vitamin E, the list goes on.

End of part 1.

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How?
Simply click here to return to Add Your Comment(s)